See car insurance rates in St. Catharines, Ontario.

Part of a series on car insurance rates in Ontario.

Car Insurance St. Catharines FAQ

Is car insurance mandatory in St. Catharines?

Car insurance is mandatory in St. Catharines, Ontario, and across the province. All drivers must meet the minimum requirement of carrying third-party liability coverage, which protects in the event of bodily injury or property damage caused to others in an accident. The minimum for third-party liability coverage in Ontario is $200,000. Additionally, drivers in St. Catharines are obligated to have direct compensation—property damage coverage (DCPD), accident benefits coverage, and uninsured motorist coverage as part of their car insurance policy.

In St. Catharines, drivers also have the choice to acquire additional types of coverage, such as collision and comprehensive insurance. It is important to recognize that the cost and availability of these supplementary coverage options can vary depending on factors such as driving history, vehicle type, and selected coverage levels. To ensure the appropriate level of coverage is obtained, it is advisable to consult with an insurance broker who can discuss individual requirements and provide expert guidance in selecting the most suitable coverage options in St. Catharines.

How do I get the best car insurance in St. Catharines?

When it comes to finding the best car insurance in St. Catharines, it is crucial to navigate through numerous options and select the coverage that aligns with your specific needs and budget. With a plethora of insurance providers offering varying rates, coverage options, and customer service experiences, the process can be overwhelming. To ensure you find the best car insurance in St. Catharines, it is essential to embark on a comprehensive process that encompasses the following steps:

Assess Coverage Needs

Assess your individual coverage needs by taking into account factors like your driving patterns, vehicle value, and financial considerations. This thorough evaluation will enable you to identify the precise coverage options that align with your requirements, striking a suitable balance between ample protection and affordability. By customizing your car insurance policy to cater to your specific circumstances, you can optimize your coverage to effectively address your distinct needs in St. Catharines.

Research Insurance Companies

Engage in extensive research on different insurance providers serving St. Catharines, delving into factors such as their industry expertise, customer satisfaction ratings, and available discounts or advantages. Focus on identifying companies with a solid reputation, financial stability, and a proven track record of delivering exceptional customer service. These qualities serve as indicators of their dedication to providing trustworthy coverage and outstanding assistance to policyholders in St. Catharines.

Read Customer Reviews

Devote some time to reviewing customer feedback and ratings of the insurance providers under consideration. This valuable step offers insights into crucial aspects such as customer service quality, claims processing efficiency, and overall satisfaction levels. By listening to the experiences of other policyholders, you gain a better understanding of an insurer’s reliability, responsiveness, and dedication to meeting customer expectations. This information empowers you to make an informed decision and select an insurance provider in St. Catharines that consistently delivers exceptional customer service and support.

Obtain Multiple Quotes

Seek quotes from multiple insurance providers to gather a diverse array of options. It is vital to furnish precise and detailed information about your driving history, vehicle specifications, and any other pertinent factors. By doing so, you ensure that the quotes you receive are customized to your specific circumstances, facilitating an informed comparison and enabling you to select the car insurance that most effectively meets your requirements in St. Catharines.

Compare Coverage and Rates

Thoroughly evaluate the coverage options, deductibles, and premiums offered by various insurance providers, considering factors such as company reputation and customer service quality. Give careful consideration to the specific coverage limits and any supplementary benefits provided, as these details significantly influence the overall value of your insurance. Through meticulous comparison, you can pinpoint the optimal balance of coverage and cost, ensuring you make an educated decision that aligns with your insurance requirements in St. Catharines.

Seek Professional Advice

Seek the advice of an insurance broker who can provide professional guidance and assist you in navigating the available options in St. Catharines. A seasoned broker possesses extensive knowledge of the insurance market and can offer tailored assistance in identifying the optimal car insurance quote that aligns with your unique requirements and budget. Leveraging their access to multiple insurance providers, brokers can conduct thorough policy comparisons, negotiate competitive rates, and provide valuable insights to facilitate an informed decision-making process. Collaborating with an insurance broker empowers you to make a well-informed choice and secure the best car insurance coverage in St. Catharines.

How much is car insurance in St. Catharines on average?

The cost of car insurance in St. Catharines, Ontario, can vary depending on factors such as the driver’s age, driving record, vehicle type, and chosen coverage levels. According to our data, the average annual cost of car insurance in St. Catharines is approximately $2,550. However, it is important to note that this figure represents an average, and individual rates can vary significantly. Factors specific to each driver’s circumstances and the insurance provider they select can result in higher or lower premiums than the average cost.

To gain a more accurate understanding of car insurance costs in St. Catharines, obtaining quotes from various insurance providers and comparing rates and coverage options is recommended. This method allows for a detailed evaluation of insurance expenses that cater to your unique needs and circumstances. By reaching out to aha insurance, you can collaborate with an insurance broker who will assist you in comparing quotes from reputable insurance companies, helping you save both time and money. Their expertise will ensure that you receive the most suitable coverage options at competitive rates in St. Catharines.

Can I lower my car insurance in St. Catharines?

Yes, there are several strategies you can consider to potentially lower your car insurance rates in St. Catharines. Here are some effective ways to reduce your premiums:

  • Increase your deductibles: Opting for a higher deductible can lower your insurance premiums. However, ensure that you choose a deductible amount you can comfortably afford to pay out of pocket in case of a claim.
  • Maintain a clean driving record: Safe driving habits and avoiding accidents or traffic violations can help you maintain a good driving record. Insurance companies often offer discounts to drivers with a clean history.
  • Bundle your policies: Consider bundling your car insurance with other insurance policies, such as home or tenant insurance, with the same provider. This can often result in discounted premiums for multiple policies.
  • Shop around for quotes: Request quotes from different insurance providers to compare rates and coverage options. This allows you to find the best value for your car insurance.
  • Inquire about discounts: Ask your insurance provider about available discounts. Many insurers offer discounts for safe driving, multi-vehicle policies, or loyalty programs. It’s worth exploring these options to potentially lower your premiums.
  • Consider your coverage needs: Review your coverage levels to ensure they align with your current needs. Adjusting coverage limits or removing unnecessary coverage can help reduce premiums.
  • Install safety features: Equipping your vehicle with safety features, such as anti-theft devices or anti-lock brakes, may make you eligible for discounts from insurance providers.

Remember to consult with your insurance provider or an insurance broker to discuss specific ways to lower your car insurance premiums in St. Catharines.

Fast facts about auto insurance in St. Catharines

Average annual car insurance rate

Regular drivers in the city

Collisions per year (approximately)


Collision rate for the city

Average age

Average household income


Unemployment rate


Understanding car insurance in St. Catharines, Ontario

St. Catharines, also known as the Garden City, sits right on the southern shore of Lake Ontario and just across the border from Buffalo, New York.

The city enjoys car insurance rates on the lower end of Ontario’s range despite its medium-high collision rate.

Part of that is because the the majority of the workforce doesn’t have to drive very far, which really limits the amount of road exposure (and statistical risk) that underpin auto insurance rates.

Less time on the road correlates to smaller chances of being in a collision.

Get your bundle on & save!

Want even cheaper insurance? Save up to 50% on home and up to 15% on car insurance when you bundle them.

Get your bundle on & save!

Want even cheaper insurance? Save up to 50% on home and up to 15% on car insurance when you bundle them.

Busting myths about driving and insurance in St. Catharines

Myth: You’ll need to commute to Hamilton, Burlington, or Oakville for work.

Wrong. According to Statistics Canada, 58% of St. Catharines workforce drives to work within the city limits. The next 30% commutes outside of the city but within Niagara Region for daily work, and a little over 11% drive outside of Niagara Region. Odds are good that you won’t need to worry about excessive exposure to risk influencing your car insurance rate.

Myth: St. Catharines has to deal with crime overflow from the States.

Some lifelong residents of the city have voiced concerns about following in the footsteps of post-industrial Buffalo just across the border, but the Garden City’s transition has more to do with the job market than crime rates.

Experiencing the same economic transition from manufacturing to service jobs doesn’t make St. Catharines dangerous.

Myth: St. Catharines has serious road maintenance issues

This might have some credibility to it. According to CAA Niagara, 3 of Niagara’s 10 worst roads in 2018 were in St. Catharines:

  • Pelham Road
  • Ontario Street
  • Merritt Street

Myth: St. Catharines isn’t safe, especially downtown.

Actually, St. Catharines sits in the middle of the pack for its overall crime severity index among cities with populations of 100,000 or more. Even better, the city enjoys the third-safest rating for violent crimes among those same cities.

The downtown core could benefit from revitalization, but it’s not a hotbed of crime, either.

How St. Catharines’ rates compare to other cities in Ontario

  • North York: $4,261
  • Etobicoke: $4,199
  • Brampton: $4,071
  • Scarborough: $3,825
  • East York: $3,605
  • Woodbridge: $3,603
  • Richmond Hill: $3,579
  • Mississauga: $3,473
  • Markham: $3,389
  • Niagara Falls: $3,321
  • Bowmanville: $3,308
  • Peterborough: $3,259
  • Pickering: $ 3,245
  • Newmarket: $ 3,216
  • Hamilton: $3,201
  • Brantford: $ 3,158
  • Maple: $3,150
  • Whitby: $3,087
  • Ajax: $3,053
  • York: $2,999
  • Toronto: $2,983
  • Barrie: $2,924
  • Thornhill: $2,871
  • Waterloo: $2,867
  • Caledon: $2,780
  • London: $2,765
  • Fort Erie: $2,720
  • Oakville: $2,720
  • Sault Ste Marie: $ 2,713
  • Kitchener: $2,705
  • Milton: $2,680
  • St Catharines: $ 2,550
  • Windsor: $2,536
  • Woodstock: $2,513
  • Innisfil: $2,505
  • Burlington: $2,476
  • Kingston: $ 2,360
  • Cambridge: $2,297
  • Oshawa: $2,295
  • Guelph: $2,268
  • Gloucester: $2,256
  • Stoney Creek: $2,222
  • Nepean: $2,196
  • Ottawa: $2,195
  • Sudbury: $2,005
  • Kanata: $2,002
  • Thunder Bay: $1,973
  • Wasaga Beach: $1,958

Quick tips on driving and insurance in Hamilton

Steer clear of St. Catharines’ most dangerous intersections.

Reduce your chances of a collision and you’ll protect your auto rates from rising. Avoid these intersections in St. Catharines to do just that:

  • Fourth and Martindale
  • Welland and Dunkirk
  • Ontario and Scott West
  • Pelham and St. Paul

Pick an a place to live with a low rate of reported crimes and claims.

Crime exists in every city, and St. Catharines is no exception. Unfortunately, higher crime rates and/or claims in a given area could influence insurance rates for everyone nearby.

That’s why it’s important to pick a place to live that doesn’t affect your rates negatively (home or auto). Try moving to a place in St. Catharines’ North End, Port Dalhousie, or Thorold North.

Watch out for speeding tickets on the QEW.

As part of a new pilot project, the QEW highway is getting a higher speed limit of 110 kilometres per hour. That’s great for commuters, but it also means you can probably expect people to drive 130 km/h instead of 120 km/h.

That could be detrimental to your car insurance rates in the wrong situation. With higher speeds come bigger insurance claims/

Watch out for speeding tickets here, too. Demerit points from speeding tickets affect your car insurance rates negatively.

Sources for fast facts about St. Catharines:

  • Statistics Canada, St. Catharines 2016 Census Profile
  • Ministry of Transportation, 2016 Road Safety Report
  • iHeart Radio Niagara, “Three Niagara roads make CAA’s top ten worst roads list for Ontario”
  • St. Catharines Standard, “QEW speed limit between Hamilton and St. Catharines increasing to 110 km/h”
  • Niagara This Week, “Correcting Globe story on St. Catharines”
  • Niagara Regional Police Service, Crime Reports
  • Niagara Independent, “St. Catharines—Niagara one of Canada’s safest metropolitan areas”
  • City News, “Speed limit to increase to 110 km/h on 3 sections of 400-series highways in pilot project”

Source for average insurance rates by city:

  • Survey of 2,800 auto insurance policy holders in Ontario

Google Rating: 4.8

Hot Dang! Those are some beautiful words from beautiful people.