I Had a Car Accident and it Was My Fault. How Does that Impact My Insurance?

If you’re involved in an accident on the road and are found to be at fault, in most cases there will be repercussions regarding your car insurance. But that doesn’t mean there aren’t steps you can take to minimize the impact.

Take note as we explain what happens after an at-fault accident and what you can do to protect yourself.

At the Scene of the Car Accident

After the car accident has occurred, it might be tempting to yell out “sorry!” and take the blame (we’re Canadian, after all). But resist the urge to do so. It’s the job of law enforcement and the car insurance companies to determine where the fault lies. It’s best to keep quiet, even if the other driver is pressuring you.

Admitting fault at the scene will only make things more difficult for you. Besides, you might actually end up falsely implicating yourself.

It’s important, however, to exchange data with the other driver. After checking for injuries, gather their insurance and contact information.

Next, call police and make a report. Do not leave the scene before they arrive. Be honest in your account of events. If an officer determines you made a violation, you may be issued a ticket. Afterward, report the incident to your car insurance company.

How Is Fault Determined?

In many cases, both drivers are partially at fault in a car accident. The insurance companies will assign different degrees of fault, regardless of whether or not you receive a ticket from police.

Ontario has strict rules regarding the determination of fault.

If you’re found to be more than 50% at fault, your insurance rates will likely increase when your policy renews. A carrier might also surcharge your insurance if you received a traffic violation or if you file a claim and are found to be at fault.

Car Accident Forgiveness

One way to protect yourself against premium increases due to an at-fault accident is to buy car accident forgiveness coverage. If you’ve got a clean record and have been driving for six years, this coverage will stop your premium from rising. It may be some time after an accident, however, in order to be granted a clean slate again.

Accident forgiveness coverage may not be purchased after an accident has occurred, and may not be available for all makes and models.

Mitigate the Blow of an At-Fault Accident

If you keep in mind the information above, you can take some of the sting out of an at-fault accident. Despite how tempting it might be to try making things right by admitting fault right away, remember it’s the job of cops and insurance agents to make that determination. Do your best to protect yourself after an accident.


Get a 3-minute quote to see what your auto insurance rates look like since your last claim.

If you’re involved in an accident on the road and are found to be at fault, in most cases there will be repercussions regarding your car insurance. But that doesn’t mean there aren’t steps you can take to minimize the impact.

Take note as we explain what happens after an at-fault accident and what you can do to protect yourself.

At the Scene of the Car Accident

After the car accident has occurred, it might be tempting to yell out “sorry!” and take the blame (we’re Canadian, after all).

But resist the urge to do so. It’s the job of law enforcement and the car insurance companies to determine where the fault lies. It’s best to keep quiet, even if the other driver is pressuring you.

Admitting fault at the scene will only make things more difficult for you. Besides, you might actually end up falsely implicating yourself.

It’s important, however, to exchange data with the other driver. After checking for injuries, gather their insurance and contact information.

Next, call police and make a report. Do not leave the scene before they arrive. Be honest in your account of events. If an officer determines you made a violation, you may be issued a ticket. Afterward, report the incident to your car insurance company.

How Is Fault Determined?

In many cases, both drivers are partially at fault in a car accident. The insurance companies will assign different degrees of fault, regardless of whether or not you receive a ticket from police.

Ontario has strict rules regarding the determination of fault.

If you’re found to be more than 50% at fault, your insurance rates will likely increase when your policy renews. A carrier might also surcharge your insurance if you received a traffic violation or if you file a claim and are found to be at fault.

Car Accident Forgiveness

One way to protect yourself against premium increases due to an at-fault accident is to buy car accident forgiveness coverage. If you’ve got a clean record and have been driving for six years, this coverage will stop your premium from rising. It may be some time after an accident, however, in order to be granted a clean slate again.

Accident forgiveness coverage may not be purchased after an accident has occurred, and may not be available for all makes and models.

Mitigate the Blow of an At-Fault Accident

If you keep in mind the information above, you can take some of the sting out of an at-fault accident. Despite how tempting it might be to try making things right by admitting fault right away, remember it’s the job of cops and insurance agents to make that determination. Do your best to protect yourself after an accident.


Get a 3-minute quote to see what your auto insurance rates look like since your last claim.

Seriously, what else can you do in 3 minutes?

Boil half an egg?

You might like these posts, too.

Do parking tickets affect insurance rates?

Do parking tickets affect insurance rates?

Few things can ruin your day as quickly as returning to your car after a night out and seeing a parking ticket tucked under your windshield wiper. Your first thoughts might be anger, confusion or angst before settling into a state of acceptance. At that point your...

read more
Cannabis and driving in Canada: what you should know

Cannabis and driving in Canada: what you should know

Cannabis is now legal in Canada, and the nation seems unable to find those scores of aunts and uncles just looking for something to help with sleep. But there are still rules we all need to follow on the road when cannabis is involved, just as with responsible...

read more
The hidden costs of buying a new car

The hidden costs of buying a new car

Buying a new car is one of the biggest financial decisions you can make in your lifetime. As a future driver, you’ll want nothing short of perfection and the very best for what your money can buy, naturally—but there are some hidden costs to buying a new car that...

read more

How are we doing?

How are we doing?